Quick FactCharter Communications merged with Time Warner Cable and Bright House Networks in 2016. Existing customers under Time Warner and Bright House have been transferred to Charter. Internet plans under the provider are now sold under the brand name “Charter Spectrum.”
AT&T Internet and Charter Spectrum are two of the most common Internet options in the US, and often compete for the same customers.
Aside from their networks, the core differences boil down to comparing their TV options, supported equipment, and overall speeds.
Charter Spectrum: Recommended For Gamers, Cord Cutters & Family Homes
- cord cutters
- family homes
Charter Spectrum is known for their cable Internet service, which pairs well with their cable TV and digital phone offerings. They’ve been progressively upgrading their networks since taking over Time Warner and Bright House. They also offer unlimited service (AT&T has data caps in most areas), making them a great choice for cord cutters. As an added bonus, they have contract-free service — a nice perk for short-term residents and renters.
AT&T Internet: Recommended For TV Fans, Renters & Budget Shoppers
- tv fans
- budget shoppers
AT&T Internet, formerly known as “AT&T U-Verse,” is traditionally a DSL provider, offering slightly slower speeds at a slightly lower price. However, they’ve been expanding their network to include fiber service in some areas, which outclasses cable and provides gigabit upload and download speeds. Keep in mind that their fiber connections are currently rare, and most customers will only have access to DSL.
Finally, there’s an outlier here: AT&T Fiber. This 100% fiber service offers some of the fastest upload and download speeds in the country at an extremely reasonable price point. It’s not for budget shoppers, but it’s our top pick if you’re in one of the few cities lucky enough to have the option. Unlike AT&T’s other plans, it has no data cap — good news for cord-cutters.
Compare AT&T Internet and Charter Spectrum at a Glance
|Statistic||AT&T Internet||Charter Spectrum|
|Price Range||$49.99 - $99.98/mo+||$49.99 - $109.99/mo+|
|Connection Type(s)||DSL, Fixed Wireless & Fiber||Cable & Fiber|
|Customer Recommendation Rating on BroadbandNow.com||41.1%||50.0%|
|ACSI Customer Service Rating||64/100||63/100|
Network Differences: Charter Spectrum Wins Out on Speed and Reliability
AT&T started as a phone provider, and their DSL network uses the same copper telephone cables that deliver landline phone service.
Charter Spectrum got their start as a cable TV provider, and their network still uses those coaxial cables originally installed for TV service.
AT&T’s DSL service is generally slower than Spectrum’s cable network. DSL usually delivers download speeds below 30 Mbps, although AT&T DSL uses advanced “Fiber to the Loop” network technology to deliver closer to 100 Mbps in some areas.
Spectrum, on the other hand, offers maximum speeds well over 100 Mbps in most areas. However, that speed often drops in the evening hours, when everyone else in the neighborhood starts maxing out the shared bandwidth with streaming services like Netflix.
In both cases, AT&T and Charter have been building out fiber network “backbones” to speed up the network. This type of network is known as “Hybrid Fiber-Coaxial” or “Fiber to the Node.” Unlike DSL (telephone wires) or cable (coaxial TV cables), fiber-optic cables are much newer and use light to transmit data rather than frequencies transmitted over copper.
For most customers, data still travels over traditional copper DSL or cable networks for the “last mile” of the network between the provider and your house. Updating this “last mile” with fiber is very expensive, which is why 100% fiber networks like AT&T Fiber are rare. Once installed, however, they require little upkeep, which makes fiber service surprisingly affordable.
Coverage Area Data for Spectrum and AT&T
Charter Spectrum Coverage & Availability Map
AT&T Internet Coverage & Availability Map
Speed Test Results for AT&T U-verse and Charter Spectrum
The big difference between AT&T and Spectrum is the network variations discussed above. But how does that translate to real-world speed results? We’ve compile speed test data on both providers so you can see the overall average performance of either network nationwide:
AT&T Internet average download speeds
Charter Spectrum average download speeds
|City||AT&T Internet Speed||Charter Spectrum Speed|
|Austin||444.51 Mbps||239 Mbps|
|Bakersfield||113.53 Mbps||164.73 Mbps|
|Birmingham||206.83 Mbps||210.08 Mbps|
|Charlotte||421.23 Mbps||228.75 Mbps|
|Cleveland||184.11 Mbps||107.9 Mbps|
|Columbus||176.75 Mbps||121.41 Mbps|
|Dallas||463.35 Mbps||227.7 Mbps|
|Dayton||167.7 Mbps||114.23 Mbps|
|El Paso||99.22 Mbps||186.98 Mbps|
|Fort Worth||306.48 Mbps||215.74 Mbps|
|Indianapolis||207.91 Mbps||191.47 Mbps|
|Kansas City||211.73 Mbps||183.39 Mbps|
|Los Angeles||300.35 Mbps||233.18 Mbps|
|Louisville||201.39 Mbps||211.14 Mbps|
|Milwaukee||367.17 Mbps||213.79 Mbps|
|Orlando||253.6 Mbps||173.33 Mbps|
|Raleigh||359.71 Mbps||221.41 Mbps|
|Saint Louis||272.26 Mbps||200.86 Mbps|
|San Antonio||311.55 Mbps||224.13 Mbps|
|San Diego||222.55 Mbps||230.01 Mbps|
Equipment and Installation
The process of installing AT&T and Charter is very similar. You can either:
- Have an installation tech come out and handle it for a small fee.
- Order a self-install package and follow the instructions.
- Purchase your own equipment and self-install.
Installation Considerations and FeesSelf-installation is advisable if you’d like to work around the standard installation fees charged by AT&T and Charter. Customers we talked to have also had success getting installation fees removed by simply asking politely on the phone — however, this can’t be guaranteed to work.
Self-installation is simple and the instructions that come with your leased modem/router device are easy to follow.
Modem and router leasing feesIf you’d like to save the $5–10/month fee for leased equipment, both AT&T and Charter allow you to purchase your own equipment instead.
This is ideal if you plan to use their service for multiple years, as the savings add up to hundreds of dollars. It is less ideal if you are a short-term resident, or if you simply don’t want to worry about setting up your own modem and router.
Each provider has their own list of specifications so far as what equipment is compatible with which services. Here’s a guide to modem and router options for AT&T, and here’s the Charter Spectrum page on modem and router options.
Buying your own equipment usually costs around $40–100 and you’re on the hook for replacement if it fails down the road, so it only makes sense for long-term customers who will recoup those savings.
AT&T Wins on TV Options
AT&T may not have the best Internet speeds in most areas, but they tip the scales for those of us who rely on solid, comprehensive TV service. They have two options:
- AT&T Prism TV: Digital TV service delivered over the same network as AT&T Internet.
- DirecTV:Satellite TV service, which was acquired by AT&T in 2014.
Of the two, DirecTV generally offers the most value, especially for sports fans. It also has nationwide availability, since it comes in via satellite. Anyone with room for a dish can get it. In the long run, AT&T will be packaging all their TV options into one product called “AT&T Entertainment.” For now, mobile customers are able to stream DirecTV channel offerings directly to all their devices free of data caps or fees — a glimpse of features to come.
Charter Spectrum’s TV service is a great budget choice when bundled with their Internet plans. However, you have to subscribe to one on their larger channel bundles in order to access premium channels like HBO, Showtime, Starz, and etc. Their sports bundles also come at a higher than average price in our experience, and sports fans who “want it all” will wind up paying a premium for it.
Deal AlertAs of August 8 2017, Charter Spectrum is offering to buy out your contract with another Internet provider to earn your service. This is a huge deal for customers locked in with an inferior cable company by steep early termination fees.
AT&T U-verse vs Charter Spectrum: Bundle Plans
If you want TV and/or phone service along with your Internet, getting a bundled deal from one provider is a no-brainer. The final rate you get is rarely as attractive as it looks up-front, but it’s always cheaper than getting services separate, not to mention less billing headache.
As a rule of thumb, Charter Spectrum is by far the best option for Internet-only customers, since they have unlimited data, faster than average speeds, and contract-free service.
AT&T has cheaper bundles in most areas, but it’s best for TV users since the Internet is generally less zippy. (At least, outside their fiber service areas.)
AT&T U-verse vs Charter Spectrum: Charter Wins for Internet Service Quality, AT&T Wins for TV Options
The bottom line with AT&T and Charter is this:
AT&T is best for customers who want “okay” Internet at a great price and spend more time watching TV than surfing the web.
Charter Spectrum is best for customers who want excellent Internet speeds and would rather “cut the cord” from cable.
Our team’s opinion is that Charter’s unlimited data and contract-free plans offer the best value for the average home.
References and Footnotes
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charter_Communications#2014.E2.80.932017:_Acquisition_of_Time_Warner_Cable_and_Bright_House ↩
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AT%26T_U-verse ↩
- https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2017/04/att-brings-fiber-to-rich-areas-while-the-rest-are-stuck-on-dsl-study-finds/ ↩
Robert Smith is a UX designer based in Brooklyn, New York. He enjoys sharing his knowledge about all things “user experience” through articles, op-eds, and how-to posts. When he’s not creating web apps, he enjoys cycling and reading classic sci-fi.
Questions & Answers
3 ANSWERED QUESTIONS
Is AT&T Fiber better than Spectrum?
Fiber service is usually better than cable, providing great reliability and gigabit speeds. AT&T’s fiber service is reasonably priced, offers some of the fastest speeds in the country and has no data caps. If you’re lucky enough to have AT&T fiber in your area and you’re not looking for a budget option, then AT&T fiber would be our top pick.
Which Internet connection is better for multiple people gaming and streaming at the same time — Spectrum or AT&T?
For heavy internet users, we recommend Spectrum. It offers reliable and fast speeds with no data caps so if you have multiple people gaming and streaming, you don’t have to worry about going over the limits. Consider their Ultra or Gig plans if they are available in your area. You can check availability for your address using our search tool.
Which is better for 4K streaming: AT&T or Spectrum?
So long as you have at least 15–25 Mbps download speed reaching your TV, 4K streaming should work without issue. I would personally recommend Spectrum since they tend to have higher download speeds.